Indice
Difference Between Flour and Semolina: Discover Their Characteristics and Uses in the Kitchen
When asking, “What’s the difference between flour and semolina?”, confusion often arises. Although both are derived from the milling of wheat, there are many differences between these two products, both nutritionally and in their culinary uses. In this article, we’ll delve into the distinctive characteristics of flour and semolina to help you make the right choice in your cooking preparations.
Soft Wheat Flour and Durum Wheat Semolina: Definitions and Differences
The primary difference between flour and semolina lies in the type of wheat they come from and how they’re processed. Soft wheat flour is obtained from the milling of soft wheat, known for its friable and opaque texture. Durum wheat semolina, on the other hand, is obtained from the milling of durum wheat, which has a more robust and translucent texture. This distinction is also reflected in the color: soft wheat flour is light yellow, while semolina has a more intense golden hue.
Nutritional Characteristics of Flour and Semolina
From a nutritional point of view, durum wheat semolina is rich in proteins, essential for the structure of doughs, and carotenoids, powerful antioxidants that give semolina its characteristic yellow color. These antioxidants are helpful in fighting free radicals and protect our body from cellular aging.
Soft wheat flour, on the other hand, is less protein-rich than semolina but has excellent extensibility and is easier to work with, making it particularly suitable for breadmaking and pastry.
Types of Soft Wheat Flour and Semolina
Soft wheat flour is divided into different categories based on the level of refinement:
- Plain Flour o Strong White Flour/ Cake Flour or Pastry Flour/ Italian type 00: Highly refined, ideal for cakes and baked goods.
- Bread Flour/All-Purpose Flour/ Italian type 0: Less refined than 00, perfect for bread and pizza.
- Strong Bread Flour o Brown Flour/Bread Flour/ Italian type 1: Richer in fiber, ideal for rustic products.
- Brown Flour o Wholemeal Bread Flour/ Whole Wheat Flour or High-Extraction Flour/ Italian type 2: Richer in fiber, ideal for rustic products.
- Wholemeal Flour/Whole Wheat Flour: Contains all parts of the grain, offering more fiber and nutrients.
Durum wheat semolina, on the other hand, is primarily divided into:
- Semolina: A granular flour from durum wheat, mainly used for making dried pasta, gnocchi, and couscous.
- Whole Wheat Semolina: Rich in fiber and nutrients due to the retention of the wheat germ and bran, used for making whole wheat pasta and bread.
- Remilled Semolina: A finer version of semolina, used especially for bread, fresh pasta, pizza, and focaccia, thanks to its smoother texture, but also for dry pasta production.
- Whole Remilled Semolina: An integral version of remilled semolina, ideal for making whole wheat bread, pasta, and baked goods that require a higher fiber and nutrient content.
Culinary Uses: When to Choose Flour or Semolina?
Uses of Soft Wheat Flour
Soft wheat flour is extremely versatile in the kitchen. Depending on the strength of the flour (measured in W), different results can be achieved:
- Weak flours (up to 180 W) are ideal for sweets like cookies, shortcrust pastry, cakes, and béchamel.
- Medium-strength flours (180-260 W) are well-suited for making fresh pasta, pizza, and soft bread.
- Strong flours (280-350 W) are used for pizza and leavened products like croissants and bread, requiring a long fermentation.
- Manitoba flour, with a W higher than 350, is the perfect choice for large leavened products such as panettone and colombe.
Uses of Durum Wheat Semolina
Durum wheat semolina is particularly suited for making pasta, both homemade and industrial, thanks to its resistance to cooking. Semolina pasta, in fact, retains its consistency and stays “al dente” better. It is also used to produce the renowned Altamura bread, as well as for preparations like focaccia, pizza, friselle, orecchiette, and traditional desserts.
Semolina, due to its coarser texture compared to remilled semolina, hydrates more easily. However, the main differences between the various types of semolina derive from the protein content and the gluten index of the wheat used. Ancient grains, while having a high protein content, tend to have a lower gluten index, making them less suitable for pasta production, as the gluten’s strength and elasticity are lower compared to modern grains, compromising cooking resistance.
Uses of Remilled Durum Wheat Semolina
Remilled semolina, due to its finer grain size, is ideal for making bread, pizzas, focaccia, and other baked goods. However, it has the same uses as traditional semolina and can also be used to prepare pasta, bread (such as Altamura bread), pizza, friselle, orecchiette, and traditional desserts.
Remilled semolina, like regular semolina, is mainly distinguished by the protein content and gluten index of the wheat used. Grains with a high protein content but low gluten index, such as ancient grains, are better suited for bread and baked goods, where gluten elasticity is less crucial than in pasta production, where this feature is essential for ensuring good cooking resistance.
Technical Differences Between Flour and Semolina Doughs
When working with soft wheat flour, the doughs are more extensible and easier to handle, thanks to the lower resistance of the gluten. This makes them ideal for manual preparations, such as fresh pasta or soft bread.
Semolina-based doughs, on the other hand, are more tenacious and require more vigorous kneading. This is due to the higher protein content and the type of gluten formed during kneading. Although less elastic, semolina doughs offer a firmer texture and superior cooking resistance.
The Most Important Choice: The Quality of Flour and Semolina
The difference between high-quality flour or semolina and a low-quality one is not only in their technical characteristics but also in their origin and processing.
Choosing artisanal flour or semolina from a short, traceable supply chain, preferably produced in Italy and purchased directly from the producer, guarantees not only superior quality but also greater control over the ingredients used.
High-quality flours and semolina should not contain glyphosate, pesticides, or added chemical additives. On the contrary, they should retain natural elements such as untreated live wheat germ, rich in valuable nutrients like B vitamins and essential fatty acids.
These aspects not only influence the taste and quality of the final product but are also crucial for a healthier, more conscious diet.
Flour and Semolina: Which to Choose for Your Preparations?
The choice between flour and semolina depends on the type of preparation and the desired result. If you need a resistant, compact pasta, durum wheat semolina is the ideal choice. For light leavened products and sweets, soft wheat flour is the perfect solution.
Both flour and semolina are key players in Italian cuisine, and by better understanding their characteristics, it will be easier to use them in the right way.
Discover our natural èViva flours and semolinas with live wheat germ, rich in nutrients and produced with passion and respect for nature. Each bag is the result of a short, controlled supply chain, without pesticides or additives, to guarantee you a genuine, high-quality product. By choosing èViva, you choose authentic taste and health at the table.
Try our èViva flours and semolinas today and transform your recipes with the authentic flavor of tradition!